Rental Property Management: Can I Choose Only Female Tenants?

Osprey Property Management   |   date June 2023

Investment property management requires a landlord to make several important decisions, including tenant selection. However, it is crucial to understand that preferring one type of tenant over another can be considered discrimination and lead to legal issues for property owners. 

So, even if you've had a better experience renting to women who take good care of your property and are excellent residents, choosing to exclude all men from your pool of eligible renters can lead to trouble. 

Today we'll share why it is important to treat all potential tenants equally and provide a fair screening process when choosing your next resident to fill a vacancy.

Why Limiting Your Tenant Criteria Can Be an Issue

We know that being comfortable with people you don't know living in your rental properties can be stressful. While property owners have the flexibility to choose the best quality resident for their properties, they must go about it in a way that's fair to every applicant, regardless of race, gender, and other protected factors. 

As a reputable landlord, providing fair and equal access to housing is essential. Discrimination based on gender is a direct violation of the principles of equality and fairness. The Fair Housing Act explicitly prohibits discrimination in housing on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, and disability. By adhering to these regulations, you ensure that all individuals have an equal chance of renting your property.A rental application, Suffolk property management company concept

For example, discriminating against male tenants by accepting applications from women and publicizing that you select only female tenants for your rental properties is a clear violation of the Fair Housing Act. Engaging in such discriminatory practices can lead to severe legal consequences, including fines, penalties, and lawsuits. 

Therefore, it is crucial to be aware of and comply with Fair Housing laws to avoid legal trouble and maintain a positive reputation as a landlord.

Limiting the Pool of Potential Tenants

By reducing your criteria to only one type of tenant, you also significantly limit the pool of potential renters for your property. This restriction can hinder your ability to find qualified and responsible tenants. Even if you prefer renting to women, there are plenty of excellent men and families in the Suffolk area who can make great renters for your properties. 

It is important to keep in mind that an individual's ability to be a good tenant is not determined by one specific aspect of who they are. Therefore, by broadening your tenant selection criteria, you increase the likelihood of finding responsible and reliable tenants.

How to Find the Best Tenants Fairly

Instead of risking claims of discrimination, it is crucial to focus on effective tenant screening methods to find good tenants. 

By implementing a thorough screening process, you can evaluate potential tenants based on their financial stability, rental history, and references. This ensures that you select tenants who are more likely to pay rent on time, maintain the property, and abide by the terms of the lease. 

To find good tenants:

  1. Create a Detailed Rental Listing: When advertising your rental property, provide a detailed and accurate description of the property, including its features, amenities, and location. Clearly outline the rental terms, such as the monthly rent, security deposit, lease duration, and any specific requirements or restrictions. 

  2. Set Clear Tenant Qualification Criteria: Establishing tenant qualification criteria helps you screen applicants effectively. Consider factors such as minimum income requirements, credit score, rental history, employment stability, and references. Clearly define these criteria and include them in your rental application. This ensures that applicants are aware of the requirements upfront, saving both parties time and effort.

  3. Thoroughly Review Rental Applications: Require prospective tenants to complete a rental application that gathers essential information, including personal details, employment history, income verification, rental history, and references. Review each application carefully and verify the information provided. 

  4. Conduct Background and Credit Checks: Performing background and credit checks is crucial to assess a tenant's financial responsibility and potential risks. Engage a reputable screening service or a property manager to obtain a comprehensive report on the applicant's credit history, criminal background, eviction history, and public records.

  5. Interview Potential Tenants: Consider conducting an interview with potential tenants to get to know them better. Use the opportunity to clarify any questions regarding the rental terms and expectations. Trust your instincts and assess whether the applicant seems reliable and trustworthy.

  6. Check References: Contact the references provided by the applicant, including previous landlords and personal references. Inquire about the applicant's character, reliability, and any issues they encountered during the tenancy. 

  7. Document the Tenant Selection Process: Keep a record of your tenant selection process, including all the applications received, the criteria used for evaluation, and the reasons for selecting or rejecting applicants.

A property manager shakes hands with a young couple, tenant screening conceptIf you find the tenant screening process challenging or overwhelming, consider consulting with a reputable property management company like the team here at Osprey Property Management. We have the expertise and resources to conduct thorough tenant screenings, ensuring you find reliable and responsible tenants while complying with Fair Housing regulations.

A Suffolk Property Management Company Finds Excellent Tenants and Protects Owners

Fair tenant selection practices are crucial for success as a rental property owner. By treating all potential tenants equally, you broaden your pool of potential renters and increase your chances of finding responsible and reliable tenants. However, if you're not sure how to follow a fair process or the idea of choosing tenants is overwhelming, let a property manager help! 

Consider reaching out to Osprey Property Management and let us guide you in selecting the best quality tenants and avoiding legal issues.


Subscribe Our Newsletter

Sign up here to get the latest news, updates and special offers delivered directly to your inbox.